When the owner of two identical dogs enters the living room to discover a box of tissues ripped up on the floor, he demands to know which one of the adorable pooches made the mess.

The answer is right in front of us.

One of the pets is unmoved by the owner’s questions, while the other is caught red-handed. Mischievous Casey is facing the wall, with a box of tissues stuck on his head. Ooouch.

Better luck next time, Casey!